Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric Rosenberg's avatar

Great article, Bret. On the evolutionary scale, technology has left mankind in the dust, and that's what makes these quantum leaps so dangerous.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Anaya Lemonnier's avatar

Thank you, Bret. I loved reading your text. I think one of the keys to understand chatGPT is that it is a text predictor, which means it can give us interesting answers by predicting what a human could have answered and it does so by processing human production on the matter. It means that these answers are like small mirrors of ourselves. We are marveled because it does look a lot like us. And indeed it does. We are predictable in things we believe are great and unique, like when a novelist sprinkles his prose with a lot of adjectives and he thinks he's being a genius. Ask chatGPT to do it and you'll see that there's nothing magical about it.

The illusion of a soul can be achieved by the AI. So what truly makes a human so special? And why would we still need humans if the illusion is good enough? And because we live in a world of illusions, because we eat illusions everyday, because our representation of reality -in our minds- is an illusion, AI seems to be deemed to success. So what is it then that distinguishes human beings from a fine-tuned prediction? What about mistakes? What if the only thing that really makes us unique is our incredible capacity of error. What about subliming errors? The rose and the cross, the lotus growing from the pestilent puddle, the blues from slavery, Nobel prizes from pogroms, etc. AI could fake that, but it would feel hollow in a sense. I hope it would... I really do. That's why I love Mexico. Plenty of mistakes everywhere but also plenty of soul and heart.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts