The Death of Analog, the Rise of the Tech Oligarchy
How the Digital Age Created a New Ruling Class—and What It Means for Democracy, Privacy, and Humanity
When President Eisenhower bid farewell in 1960, he delivered a stark warning about the growing dangers of the Military-Industrial Complex—a cautionary note that history has since validated. Now, as President Biden prepares to leave office, he issues a warning of his own: the rise of a Tech Oligarchy. This time, however, we don’t need to wait for history to confirm it. The reality is unfolding right in front of us.
Forty years ago, the world hummed with the sound of dial tones, cassette tapes, and the clatter of typewriters. Televisions beamed sitcoms and nightly news into our living rooms at scheduled times, and radios kept us company on long drives. Information came from newspapers delivered to the doorstep or encyclopedias lining the shelves. It was analog, tangible, and slow—but it was also grounded in a reality we could see and touch. Fast-forward to today, and we’re living in a digital whirlwind, hurtling through a world shaped by screens, algorithms, and invisible networks. Somewhere along the way, we traded the physical for the virtual, and in doing so, we handed over the reins of our lives to the architects of this digital universe: the tech oligarchs.
Joe Biden isn’t sounding the alarm about a distant possibility—he’s pointing at the storm already raging overhead. The rise of the tech oligarchy is the story of how technology transformed from a tool to a tyrant, reshaping every aspect of society in the process. What began as innovation to improve lives—computers in classrooms, mobile phones to stay connected, the internet to democratize knowledge—has metastasized into something unrecognizable. Now, instead of empowering individuals, technology serves the interests of a few billionaires who wield it like a modern-day Sword of Damocles, dangling it over the rest of us.
Think back to the 1980s. Computers were bulky, beige boxes reserved for offices and hobbyists. A household with a Commodore 64 or an IBM PC was ahead of the curve. The internet? It was still a government experiment, a rudimentary network called ARPANET. By the 1990s, the World Wide Web burst onto the scene, promising to connect humanity. It was a revolution, but one with naïve optimism. Remember AOL chatrooms, GeoCities websites, and email? It all seemed so innocent, a digital playground where everyone was equal. But even then, the seeds of today’s tech oligarchy were being planted.
Fast-forward to the 2000s. The analog world faded into the background as digital took over. Google became synonymous with knowledge. Amazon transformed how we shop. Facebook turned our social lives into data. By the 2010s, smartphones had become extensions of our bodies, carrying more computing power in a pocket than NASA had during the Apollo missions. The tech companies didn’t just make tools; they made ecosystems—walled gardens where they controlled everything from access to content to how it was monetized.
Now we live in a world where the physical and digital are inseparable. Our homes are filled with smart devices listening to us. Our jobs depend on cloud servers. Our relationships play out on apps. It’s as if the analog world has died, and the digital world has risen in its place, a Frankenstein’s monster created by Silicon Valley and unleashed on an unsuspecting public.
The consequences of this shift are staggering. Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg are not just business leaders; they’re the new kings of a borderless empire. Musk controls the future of transportation and communication, from self-driving cars to satellites that beam the internet to every corner of the globe. Bezos has built a retail behemoth that crushes competition and reshapes labor markets while dabbling in space colonization. Zuckerberg sits atop a mountain of user data, wielding algorithms that dictate what billions of people see, believe, and feel. Together, these men hold the power to shape reality—and that’s exactly what they’re doing.
What does that mean for us, the billions who live in the shadow of their ambitions? It means a world where privacy is a relic of the past. Every click, every search, every conversation is harvested, analyzed, and sold. It means a world where misinformation spreads faster than truth, where elections can be influenced by a tweak in an algorithm, and where social cohesion dissolves into echo chambers and outrage. It means a world where economic inequality deepens, as automation and gig work replace stable jobs, leaving millions struggling while a handful of tech moguls rake in billions.
And if we keep walking this path, what comes next? The death of democracy, for starters. How can people make informed choices when their information is filtered through platforms designed to maximize engagement, not truth? How can governments regulate industries when tech giants have the resources to out-lobby entire nations? This isn’t just a slippery slope—it’s a cliff edge.
Then there’s the existential threat of what the tech oligarchy calls “innovation.” AI, space colonization, virtual reality—these aren’t just tools; they’re the foundations of a future where the elite escape the problems they’ve created, leaving the rest of us behind. Picture Bezos on a luxury space station while Earth chokes on pollution. Picture Musk’s AI replacing entire industries, leaving millions unemployed. Picture Zuckerberg’s Metaverse, a digital escape hatch where people plug in because reality has become too unbearable.
But this isn’t science fiction—it’s happening now. We’re already living in the early stages of this dystopia. The analog world is dead, and the digital world is eating itself alive, driven by the insatiable greed of the few at the top. If we don’t act, the consequences will be irreversible.
This is life and death. It’s the life of democracy, fairness, and opportunity versus the death of privacy, equality, and truth. It’s the life of a society where technology serves humanity versus the death of one where humanity serves technology.
The question isn’t whether we can go back to the analog days. We can’t. The digital age is here to stay. The question is whether we let the tech oligarchs define what it means to live in this age—or whether we take back control. We need antitrust action to break up monopolies, regulations to protect privacy and curb misinformation, and a cultural shift that values people over profits.
The stakes couldn’t be higher. If we fail, the tech oligarchy won’t just dominate our lives—they’ll define our deaths. And the American Dream, once a beacon of hope and progress, will fade into the dim glow of a screen, forgotten in the scroll.
The time to act is now. Turn off autopilot. Look up from your phone. The algorithm isn’t going to save us—but maybe, just maybe, we can save ourselves.
Perhaps the most alarming part of this unfolding digital dystopia is how utterly complacent Americans have become. We’ve traded our agency for convenience, our privacy for connectivity, and our critical thinking for curated feeds. The algorithm knows what we want before we do—so why bother questioning it? Need groceries? Amazon will deliver them to your doorstep. Want entertainment? Netflix and TikTok have endless streams waiting. Feeling outraged? Social media is happy to provide a tailor-made echo chamber to stoke your rage. In exchange, we’ve handed over our data, our attention, and, ultimately, our freedom.
This complacency isn’t an accident; it’s the system working as designed. The tech oligarchs thrive on our inertia, our willingness to scroll instead of act, to consume instead of challenge. Entire institutions, from governments to the media, have fallen into the same trap—seduced by the power of Big Tech or simply too slow to keep up with its pace. As Americans retreat further into digital bubbles, the tech oligarchy’s grip tightens.
Enter Donald Trump, who has not only mastered the art of manipulating technology for his own ends but is now actively forging alliances with the tech elite to strengthen his position. While his first presidency saw him at odds with some Silicon Valley leaders—particularly after he was de-platformed by major social media companies following the January 6 Capitol riots—the landscape is shifting. The tech bros, once perceived as libertarian idealists or apolitical innovators, are increasingly embracing Trump as a tool for their own ends.
Why? Because Trump represents something the tech oligarchs crave: unfettered deregulation and an ideological alignment that prioritizes profit over principles. His administration gutted regulatory agencies, cut corporate taxes, and openly embraced monopolistic practices in the name of economic growth. It’s no coincidence that Big Tech’s dominance skyrocketed during his first term. Now, as Trump begins a second four years in office, tech leaders see an opportunity to double down.
Figures like Elon Musk, once considered eccentric but largely apolitical, have made their support for Trump’s worldview increasingly clear. Musk’s acquisition of X (formerly Twitter) has turned the platform into a haven for right-wing discourse, where Trump’s voice echoes louder than ever. By reinstating Trump’s account and amplifying controversial voices, Musk has effectively aligned himself with the MAGA movement, positioning X as a tool for Trump’s return to power.
Peter Thiel, one of the original PayPal founders and a prominent tech investor, has long been a staunch supporter of Trump. Thiel’s libertarian leanings align perfectly with Trump’s disdain for government oversight, and his financial backing of MAGA candidates underscores the deepening ties between Silicon Valley money and Trump’s political machine.
Even Mark Zuckerberg, who once tried to maintain a veneer of neutrality, has shifted tactics. Meta’s platforms—Facebook and Instagram—are still riddled with disinformation, much of it favoring Trump’s agenda. Despite public commitments to curb harmful content, Meta’s algorithms continue to prioritize engagement above all else, creating fertile ground for Trump’s rhetoric to thrive. And now, he’s eliminated independent verification.
And it’s not just the individual tech leaders. The broader tech ecosystem is complicit. Cloud computing companies host far-right platforms. AI tools are being weaponized to spread propaganda. Data analytics firms tied to Big Tech are helping political campaigns micro-target voters with chilling precision. The tech industry’s collective support may not always be overt, but it is unmistakably present in the infrastructure it provides and the profits it reaps.
Trump, for his part, is exploiting these alliances to their fullest potential. While he rails publicly against the “liberal media” and Big Tech censorship, he’s quietly building a tech empire of his own. Truth Social, his social media platform, may seem like a niche player now, but it represents a broader strategy: to create a parallel digital ecosystem where Trump controls the narrative. Coupled with his alliances with figures like Musk and Thiel, Trump’s tech arsenal is becoming a powerful weapon.
What does this mean for the future? Imagine the second Trump presidency, bolstered not just by his base but by the full might of the tech oligarchy. The same algorithms that drive engagement could be used to amplify propaganda, suppress dissent, and manipulate public opinion on an unprecedented scale. Surveillance tools could be weaponized to target opponents, while platforms like X and Truth Social create echo chambers that deepen polarization. The result would be a fusion of state power and corporate influence that makes the current dystopia look quaint by comparison.
The complacency of the American public only makes this scenario more likely. We’re so accustomed to living in a world mediated by screens that we’ve stopped questioning who’s behind them. The tech oligarchs may not have political ambitions themselves, but they see in Trump a partner who will protect their interests while further entrenching their dominance.
This isn’t just a warning—it’s a wake-up call. The rise of a tech oligarchy isn’t happening in isolation. It’s unfolding in a society where apathy is the norm, and opportunists like Trump are poised to seize the moment. If we don’t shake off our digital stupor, the future won’t just be shaped by the tech elite—it’ll be weaponized by those who know how to use it for power.
The stakes couldn’t be higher. With Trump’s return to power, the tools of the tech oligarchy could become instruments of oppression, division, and authoritarian control. Without decisive action to curb their influence and break the dangerous alliance between tech and politics, we risk losing more than our democracy—we risk losing our humanity.
For more, take a deep dive:
On Monday: Welcome to the Fillmore East - New York, New York 1970. Until then, let your conscience be your guide.
Retreating into silence, making the news of the bad world "go away," brings a person closer to despair and some even to suicide. "Nothing can be done," says one tramp to another in *Waiting for Godot*, a play in which frustration and powerlessness of (absurdly sub-)ordinary people appear to thwart their hope and expectation of a better future. Of course each person who reads or attends the play can respond freely based on their creeds and values. This is where most of Bret's readers live. I'll bet that most agree with him that anyone who wants liberty and justice for all, a "fair shot" (Biden's phrase) at a better future for everyone, will talk with their friends and neighbors, join movements, write their congressional, state and local leaders to do right for all. Where necessary, they'll work up petitions for fairer voting rules and get majorities to vote on certain issues, tough work in some states. But in recent years I've seen it work. Then there are courts, not all with judges appointed by rightists. Determination, willingness to work hard, active hope and faith in most of the citizenry to see reason will have to be stoked and encouraged by people of goodwill. Maybe someone will help by starting to sing, "We Shall Overcome" or "If We Only Have Love."
What an amazing essay! It doesn't need to be prophetic. It's accurate; simply true as written, Bret. Makes me want to say OW! But that doesn't nearly cover the kind of shit we're in at this moment in history.